Book or Movie? Which Should You Choose?
As a mom who loves reading, I’ve always enjoyed comparing books and their movie adaptations. There’s something fun about reading a book, imagining the characters and settings, and then watching how Hollywood brings it to life – sometimes it’s fantastic, and sometimes it falls short. Over the years, I’ve noticed there are some stories where the book is unforgettable, some where the movie steals the show, and a few rare ones where both are equally wonderful. Here are a few of my favorites lately:
.
.
The Boys in the Boat
.
–
I love, LOVE this book. It’s one of my all-time favorites! It’s beautifully written, full of grit, teamwork, and history. The movie was good, but lacked the depth, detail, and emotion that made the book so powerful. Perhaps I would have liked it better if I hadn’t just finished the book.
Verdict:The book is a MUST READ. The movie would be a good family night options (for kids ages 10 and up), but the book is SO MUCH BETTER.
Click here for the audio book! Listen while you work or drive.
.
.
–
Redeeming Love
.
The book, written by Francine Rivers, goes deep into themes of forgiveness, redemption, and unconditional love. The movie does a good job staying true to the story, but like most adaptations, it misses some of the emotional layers and character development that make the book unforgettable.
Verdict: Read or listen to the book first, but both the book and movie are powerful, emotional and well done.
.
.
.
All the Light We Cannot See by Anthony Doerr
.
.
Both are beautifully done, and the story itself is a little sad, but rich and hopeful. I watched the Netflix series first, so the book didn’t hold the same suspense for me.
Verdict: If you’re short on time, the series is lovely. If you want rich, poetic writing, go for the book. Click here for the audiobook.
.
.
.
Because of Winn-Dixie
.
.
Both versions are wonderful! The book by Kate DiCamillo is charming, heartfelt, and timeless. The movie captures that same sweetness perfectly. This is a rare case where both are wonderful.
Verdict: You can’t go wrong either way. Read it with your kids, then make popcorn and watch the movie together.
Considering downloading the audio book and listening together as a family? Click here to find the audiobook.
.
.
.
The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe
.
.
The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe is one of the best children’s books ever written.. It’s full of wonder, imagination, and deep meaning. When I finished reading this book with my two youngest sons, they said, “Can you find another book JUST like this.” That’s a hard task because this book is one-of-a-kind. The movie is a great family film that brings Narnia to life beautifully, but it can’t quite match the depth of the book.
Verdict: Read the book first. The movie is a wonderful follow-up.
.
Click here to listen to the audiobook together!
–
–
Books and movies each have their place, sometimes one outshines the other, and sometimes they work hand in hand. But if I had to choose, I almost always recommend starting with the book. There’s just something special about imagining the story for yourself before seeing it unfold on screen.
Personal Note: I just finished a fascinating biography about Eric Liddell and can’t wait to finally watch Chariots of Fire. Some stories are worth enjoying in both formats!
.
Love books but short on time? For a limited time, get an Audible membership for just 99¢/month!
- Audible has a huge amount of books and podcasts available in audio format – listen on any device, anytime.
- Audible credits are cheaper than if you wanted to purchase one audiobook.
- Audible allows you to save credits and if you decide to cancel your membership you won’t lose the books you’ve already purchased!
Click here to get this fantastic, limited-time deal!
.
Click here to check out my first post: Read the Book or Watch the Movie!
Click here to read last post on “BOOKS vs MOVIES.”
.
Click here to read the BEST BOOKS OF THE YEAR!
Thanks for reading and please consider subscribing!
Disclaimer: This post contains affiliate links.